data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/42f95/42f959c39d1527f2bb19fa00f0b7c8651aea6393" alt="Beautiful Ugly"
My rating: 2 of 5 stars
Let me first start off by saying I don't read this type of book normally. Adult fiction is not my thing unless it's romance. I'm attending a book club with this book and honestly thought based on the synopsis I might enjoy it a bit.
I did not.
Also? This review will have spoilers. Read at your own risk.
Grady is a selfish and childish character. I get it. So am I on occasion. Wanting to be in your own little bubble and do what you want to do? Totally me. Doesn't mean I want to read about a person with similar traits. I don't care that he can't write a book after his wife disappearance.
I thought it was cool that he went to a remote island to write in peace and quiet. I'd like to do that but to read said books.
A few things I really just flat out disliked? The narration. I get the author wanted to keep us confused. But we were falsely mislead multiple times with Abby's narrative. It says one week before disapperance. Since most of those chapters were not Grady's wife, and happened YEARS ago, that is incorrect information. So the reader was never given a chance to figure out the different characters.
The Island. Why do I hate it? There are so many lore stories for every section - the 5 mile apart island. I'm sure history is a big deal for these residents, but I really couldn't give a care while reading.
I really wanted to love the whole women are better without men so they can't live here bit. But it just fell flat for me for some reason. I'm all about women being empowered but these women were just.... I can't explain why I was let down by that part.
And finally. Grady attempting to kill Abby. Wasnt he on the phone with her when she found him? Was he legit on the ground on his phone taking to her? That whole bit was confusing and seemed rushed.
The only good thing about this book? The dog survives. That's why I have it 2 stars.
View all my reviews
View all my reviews